Montello Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Montello, Wisconsin – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Marquette County! This charming city offers a perfect blend of small-town warmth and natural beauty, making it an ideal destination for families, retirees, and everyone in between. With its picturesque landscapes, friendly community, and a rich history, Montello is a place where you can truly feel at home.

One of the standout features of Montello is its affordability. With a variety of homes available for under $500,000, you can find the perfect property without breaking the bank. Whether you’re looking for a cozy cottage by the lake, a spacious family home, or a quaint bungalow, Montello has something to suit every taste and budget. The real estate market here is thriving, offering a range of options that cater to first-time buyers and seasoned investors alike.

Beyond its attractive housing market, Montello boasts an array of outdoor activities that will delight nature enthusiasts. Explore the stunning Montello River, perfect for fishing and kayaking, or take a leisurely hike through the nearby parks and trails. The city’s vibrant community hosts various events throughout the year, from farmers' markets to seasonal festivals, ensuring there’s always something happening.

In Montello, you’re not just purchasing a home; you’re investing in a lifestyle filled with adventure, community, and tranquility. Discover your dream home in Montello today and experience the charm of this delightful Wisconsin city!

Newest Montello Homes under $500,000

$65,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Opportunity awaits in a convenient Montello location! This property offers a chance to create a home that reflects your own style and vision. This house was used as a 5-bedroom home, with 2 bedrooms featuring closets. While it does need repairs and updating, it has plenty of potential for an owner-occupant looking to build equity, a buyer ready to take on a renovation project, or an investor searching for their next opportunity. Bring your ideas and see what this property could become! Property is being sold as-is and will not qualify for government-backed financing.

147 Douglas Avenue, Montello

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Local Realty.

$349,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Exceptional New construction built with comfort, convenience and accessibility in mind. Built by one on the areas most respected builders, this home is designed for ease of living with a seamless open floorplan that's perfect for both relaxing and entertaining. The kitchen features custom Amish built cabinetry, quartz countertops & island, vaulted ceilings with LED lighting and a generous walk-in pantry. The spacious open living room features sliders to a large elevated deck perfect for grilling, relaxing or adding extra guest space to the living room. Main floor has 2 bedrooms, 2 baths & convenient main floor laundry while the english basement has the 3rd bedroom & 3'rd bathroom. 9 foot ceilings in the lower level add a dramatic expansive look to the cozy family room! Plenty of storage between the lower level utility room and attached 2-car garage. Outside, the front & back yards even have an in-ground sprinkler system! Expert craftsmanship and everything brand new hurry!

328 Brooke Circle, Montello

Listing courtesy of Cotter Realty LLC.

$299,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Enjoy waterfront living in the heart of Montello! This 2-story home offers 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, a 2-car garage and approximately 200 feet of frontage on the Montello River with beautiful views overlooking Buffalo Lake from the primary bedroom deck. Step outside and fish right from your own backyard, launch a kayak, or simply relax along the water & enjoy the scenery. The river frontage provides direct access to the area's fishing and recreational opportunities while still offering the convenience of being right in Montello. Whether you're looking for a year-round residence, weekend getaway or waterfront retreat, this property offers a great combination of location &recreation. Imagine mornings overlooking the water, afternoons spent fishing from your backyard and evenings relaxing along the river. The woodwork in the home really gives you that up north cabin feel. An opportunity to own approximately 200 feet of waterfront and enjoy everything the Montello River and Buffalo Lake offer

117 S Main Street, Montello

Listing courtesy of United Country Midwest Lifesty.

$145,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Perfect setting to enjoy year round or as a retreat. This 2 bedrm / 1 bath mobile home offers an open floor plan, additional add on family room on main level and a lower level bonus room as well. Located on a quite dead end road. Home surrounded by mature oakes & pines. Oversize 2+ car dettached garage, gazebo, deck and fenced in yard. You will appreciate the privacy.

W1724 W 19th Court, Montello

Listing courtesy of First Weber Inc.

$300,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Looking for a lake property, a year round residence or a potential investment property, look no further. This 3 bedroom, 2 bath home on Buffalo lake is available to make some memories. Main level features 3 bedrooms and a full bath, downstairs is the kitchen and living space and large 3 seasons space to enjoy steps from the lake. Great features of this property are a new well and septic, paved driveway and pier. Enjoy year round lake living on a low traffic property.

3730 W Oak Street, Montello

Listing courtesy of Showen Properties.

$398,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Welcome Home to modern comfort in Montello! Skip the wait of building and step straight into luxury with this pristine, brand new construction ranch home with additional finished space in the lower level. Crafted by a premiere local builder known for meticulous attention to detail, this property combines modern finishes with the peace of mind that only new construction can offer. Large kitchen/dining space with custom built Amish cabinetry & large center island. Generous 3-bedroom, 3 full bath design with optimized space for main level entertaining. Primary suite complete with spacious walk-in closet & ensuite bath thoughtfully designed with walk in shower. Laundry on the main for added convenience. Fully finished lower level with rec room, additional bedroom & full bath along with additional finished bonus room ideal for an office. Enjoy the perfect blend of country quiet with the convenience of schools, restaurants and local shops just a few minutes away! Buyer to verify room sizes.

W2767 Whitetail Lane, Montello

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Local Realty.

$99,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Well maintained 2 bedroom cottage with access to lake puckaway where the sunsets never disappoint. Newer furnace and central A/C. New flooring and newer roof. Open concept! Deeded access to lake puckaway with private boat launch and dock access! Dont miss out!

W1718 Fur Drive, Montello

Listing courtesy of KWS Realty (Kathy Wolf and Sons Realty).

$355,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Beautifully updated, move-in ready 2BR, 1.5BA accessible ranch home on Buffalo Lake offering 1,443 sq. ft. of single-story waterfront living! The bright, sun-drenched kitchen features modern white cabinetry, sleek quartz counters, stainless steel appliances, brushed nickel hardware, breakfast bar pass-through and wood burning FP. Enjoy breathtaking water views from your low-maintenance, upper and lower Trex composite decks, or utilize the rare, highly coveted grandfathered boat house at the water's edge. Set on an expansive 18,295 sq. ft. lot, the property includes a 2-car detached garage, a free-standing shed, and additional attic storage. Unwind with total peace of mind thanks to major capital updates since 2011, including a new roof (2014), furnace 2015, septic system inspected 4/2026, flooring, and trim. Smart home features include an app-controlled Honeywell Wi-Fi thermostat, with July 2023 well, water, on file.

W4043 County Rd C Road, Montello

Listing courtesy of Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Special Properties.

$469,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Welcome home to the perfect blend of modern luxury and small-town charm in this stunning 3 bed/2bath new construction home, proudly built by one of the area's most well-respected builders. Enjoy a spacious, sunlit living and dining area perfect for entertaining or relaxing with family. Large kitchen is equipped with a large center island, custom Amish cabinetry and a complete stainless steel appliance package. Primary bedroom features a large walk-in closet along with en-suite bath with walk in shower. A generous, level lot offers endless possibilities for the use of your outdoor space. Just minutes away from the conveniences of downtown Montello and close to numerous local lakes. Home also has a zero-step entrance and is wheelchair accessible. Room sizes approx., buyer to verify if material.

N3425 Flynn Drive, Montello

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Local Realty.

$349,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Welcome to peaceful country living in rural Montello! This 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath ranch home sits on nearly a half-acre, offering the perfect blend of space, comfort, & outdoor enjoyment. Step inside and you?ll immediately be drawn to the stunning floor-to-ceiling gas fp ? a true focal point that adds warmth & character to the main living area. The updated kitchen features ample cabinetry, tile backsplash and great flow into the dining area. Freshly painted interior. New windows (N & W side of house, 2024). Outside is where this property really shines! Enjoy your own backyard retreat with an awesome firepit area ? perfect for summer evenings under the stars, gathering with friends, or simply relaxing. There?s plenty of room to play, garden, or just spread out and enjoy the rural surroundings. Home warranty for peace of mind. This is one you won?t want to miss!

N3337 Whitetail Court, Montello

Listing courtesy of First Weber Inc.

$275,000

8 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Looking for a large 1 story ranch style home for all your needs? this is it, if you home school, work out of your home, have a home business, or maybe you have a large family and need lots of bedrooms office area and storage. This home is perfectly set up with a large central kitchen area, large dining room and a huge living room to hang out. Everything on 1 floor with a great open floor plan. Plenty of parking if you have several vehicles, outside patio and a large yard for kids and pets to run. Located in the heart of Montello just off of Hwy 22. If you work or commute out of the area, this is an easy access property, close to Madison, Portage, Green Lake and the Fox valley area. If you love the outdoors, there are many activities for all season. Close to Buffalo Lake, Montello Lake, Green Lake, Lake Puckaway, for all your boating fun. Many local state and county parks for hiking biking, camping and outdoor fun. Plenty of work and shopping. Choice of Two homes, 497A or 497B Lake St.

497B Lake Street, Montello

Listing courtesy of United Country Midwest Lifesty.

$299,900

8 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

497A Lake Street, Montello

Listing courtesy of United Country Midwest Lifesty.

Start Your Search

Copyright 2026 WIREX Multiple Listing Service. All rights reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Information is supplied by seller and other third parties and has not been verified.