Amherst Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Amherst, Wisconsin – a charming village nestled in the heart of Portage County. Known for its stunning natural landscapes and a tight-knit community, Amherst offers a perfect blend of rural tranquility and modern convenience. With its picturesque views, friendly neighborhoods, and a rich tapestry of local culture, this hidden gem is an ideal place to call home.

Amherst boasts a vibrant community spirit, with a variety of local events and festivals that celebrate the area’s unique heritage. The village is surrounded by beautiful parks and outdoor recreational opportunities, making it a haven for nature enthusiasts. Whether you enjoy hiking, fishing, or simply taking in the scenic beauty of the Wisconsin countryside, Amherst has something for everyone.

For those looking to settle down in this delightful village, the real estate market offers an impressive selection of homes under $400,000. From charming single-family residences to modern townhouses, there’s a diverse range of options to suit various lifestyles and budgets. These homes often feature spacious yards, updated interiors, and easy access to local amenities, ensuring that you can enjoy the best of both comfort and convenience.

With its affordable housing options and a welcoming atmosphere, Amherst is an excellent choice for first-time homebuyers, families, and retirees alike. Discover the warmth of this wonderful community and find your dream home in Amherst, where every day feels like a breath of fresh air. Explore the possibilities that await you in this enchanting village, and make Amherst your next home sweet home!

Newest Amherst Homes under $400,000

$199,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Discover the possibilities with this 5.4-acre farmette in Amherst with beautiful views. Ideal for a hobby farmer, homesteader, or anyone looking for room to spread out, this property offers a peaceful and private country setting with plenty of open space. An older dairy barn and several additional outbuildings provide excellent options for animals, equipment, storage, workshops, or future projects. Enjoy the charm of rural living with space for gardens, chickens, livestock, or recreational use. A unique opportunity to create your own country retreat and bring new life to this former Amish farmstead.

7973 Old Amish Road, Amherst

Listing courtesy of Geiger, Realtors.

$297,500

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Welcome to 188 Pond Street in Amherst! This spacious 3-bedroom, 1-bath home sits on a large lot overlooking the scenic Tomorrow River and offers a great combination of space, privacy, and convenience. Inside, you?ll find a bright and open living area with hardwood-style flooring, recessed lighting, and a stone accent wall, along with a well-appointed kitchen featuring plenty of cabinet and counter space, a large peninsula for additional seating, and an easy flow into the main living areas. The updated bathroom features a tiled walk-in shower, while the large wraparound deck provides plenty of space for relaxing, entertaining, or taking in the wooded surroundings and river views. Outside, the expansive yard offers plenty of room for recreation, gardening, or future possibilities. The oversized two-car garage is another major highlight, offering excellent space for vehicles, toys, or a workshop, plus a large storage loft above for even more usable space. The garage is also plumbed for in floor heat. Conveniently located near downtown Amherst while still offering a peaceful setting ov,This information is compiled from miscellaneous sources and is believed accurate but not warranted. Neither the listing broker nor its agents, subagents or property owner are responsible for the accuracy of the information. Buyers are advised to verify all information.

188 Pond Street, Amherst

Listing courtesy of FIRST WEBER.

126 Wilson Street Unit 136/ 146 Wilson Stre, Amherst

$212,500

ACTIVE Status

Nice investment opportunity. Triplex in the Village of Amherst with great rental income of $2,140/month or $25,680/year, with tenants paying all utilities: natural gas, electric, sewer and water. The lower-level unit is 126 Wilson Street, with rent of $565/month is a one-bedroom, lease expires 06/30/2027. The main-level unit is 136 Wilson Street, with rent of $775/month is a two-bedroom, lease is no term and does not expire until 08/31/2028. The upper-unit is 146 Wilson Street, with rent of $800/month is a two-bedroom, lease expires 05/31/2027. All written leases, with security deposits equal to monthly rent. Owner just finished having all new replacement windows installed. Upper-level unit was recently remodeled. Great location in the Village of Amherst next to the International Bank of Amherst. Strong rental history with supporting income.,This information is compiled from miscellaneous sources and is believed accurate but not warranted. Neither the listing broker nor its agents, subagents or property owner are responsible for the accuracy of the information. Buyers are advised to verify all information.

126 Wilson Street Unit 136/ 146 Wilson Stre, Amherst

Listing courtesy of FIRST WEBER.

$295,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Welcome to this spacious and versatile 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath home in Amherst, offering plenty of room to spread out and make it your own. One of the standout features is that all three bedrooms offer walk-in closets, providing exceptional storage throughout. The large kitchen offers plenty of cabinetry and generous countertop space, giving you lots of room for cooking, meal prep, and entertaining. In addition to the three bedrooms, there is an extra room that can easily adapt to your needs, use it as a home office, playroom, craft room, hobby space, guest area, or whatever works best for your lifestyle. The finished basement adds even more living and entertaining space and includes an additional bonus room perfect for a home theater, game room, sports lounge, entertainment room, or your own private retreat. With so many flexible spaces, this home gives you the opportunity to create areas that truly fit the way you live. Outside, you?ll appreciate the attractive setting, mature trees, spacious yard, attached garage, and welcoming curb appeal. If you?ve been looking for a home with ,Information Is Compiled From Miscellaneous Sources & Is Believed Accurate, But Not Warranted. Neither The Listing Broker Nor Its Agents,Subagents Or Property Owner Are Responsible For The Accuracy Of The Information. Buyers Are Advised To Verify All Information.

511 Mill Street, Amherst

Listing courtesy of STEVENS POINT REALTY INC.

$264,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Waterfront, Waterfront, Waterfront!! Check out this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath waterfront home in the highly desirable Amherst area, conveniently located close to schools, restaurants, parks, and so many local businesses! Situated on a spacious 0.72-acre lot with 100 feet of water frontage, this property offers plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors, relax, or entertain guests! Enjoy time in the water or around the fire pit making memories. Summertime will be a blast! Inside, you'll find beautiful hardwood floors flowing throughout the home, a large dining room, comfortable living space, a huge kitchen with plenty of storage, and a convenient main-floor bathroom. Upstairs features all three bedrooms, including one with charming built-in beds that add character and functionality. With 1,496 finished square feet, this home offers tons of classic charm, comfortable living, and the convenience of being close to everything Amherst has to offer. Don't wait, call us today to schedule your showing! This waterfront gem won't last long!

338 N Main Street, Amherst

Listing courtesy of KPR BROKERS, LLC.

$319,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Step inside this newly updated 1.5-story Amherst home featuring three bedrooms, one-and-one-half bathrooms, and a thoughtfully updated interior. Situated on .98 acres, the property offers a wonderful balance of indoor comfort and outdoor space. The backyard creates a peaceful setting for relaxing, gardening, entertaining, or simply enjoying the surroundings. Located within the Tomorrow River School District and approximately one mile from the Amherst school campus, the home offers convenient access to the community while maintaining a welcome sense of space and privacy. Per seller, the furnace/AC, electrical, and well are all three years old. The hot tub is included in the sale. With its refreshed interior, generous lot, and private backyard, this home is ready for its next owner.

9787 County Road Kk, Amherst

Listing courtesy of KPR BROKERS, LLC.

$215,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Step into the charm of this beautifully updated 1850s home, where historic character meets modern comfort. This move-in ready 1.5-story home features 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and stylish updates throughout. Enjoy the convenience of an attached insulated garage and relax on the inviting covered porch. The spacious 22x9 walk-in attic offers excellent storage or potential for future expansion. Outside, you'll find a patio perfect for entertaining, a nice corner lot, and plenty of outdoor space to enjoy. A wonderful blend of timeless appeal and modern touches, this home is ready for its next owner.

201 Mill Street, Amherst

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Lyons Real Estate.

Start Your Search

Copyright 2026 WIREX Multiple Listing Service. All rights reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Information is supplied by seller and other third parties and has not been verified.